Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

For short-term yes. For long-term, how do you deal with overbuilding and/or large groups of people moving away to the next up-and-coming city, leaving behind a ghost town of empty high rises?

Some overbuilt cities in China or Eastern Europe have that issue.



Overbuild cities in China or Eastern Europe are artifacts of planning gone wrong, not the opposite.


I was addressing parent's "There should be no zoning at all". Maybe I'm confusing zoning and urban planning.


Zoning and urban planning are very closely interrelated. Zoning (obviously) is an instance of urban planning - and it's very hard to plan a city if you don't have a way of enforcing your plan (zoning).

The China and Eastern Europe ghost-cities are slightly different because the distinction between the zoning authority (government) and the developer is more fluid, but I still think it applies.


Those cities we're built by bureaucracy, not the market. In fact, what you mention is a great example of failed social planning which is taking zoning to the next level.


How is this a zoning issue?


Is that clearly a bad thing? Maybe the market is correctly accounting for the cost vs value? I mean, is there some externality I'm missing?


Waste?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: